Skip to Main Content
Share

Find Your Slice of the Pi in Cortland County

Mar 06, 2025
Experience Cortland
2 mins
20231005 hollenbecks photo credit matt baldelli 08
© Matt Baldelli

Math and pie lovers unite! March 14th is a chance to celebrate everyone's favorite mathematical constant "π", or 3.14. For the hungry though, National Pi Day is the perfect excuse to indulge in all things pie.

To celebrate the most fantastic mathematical-themed day of the year, we have put together our favorite pie eats around Cortland County. Be it pizza pie, dessert pie, or even savory Shepard's pie, there is something on the menu for all palettes.

So put down your calculators and mathematical gadgets and pick up a fork. It's about to be a delicious day in Cortland County!


CARMPLE APPLE CRUMBLE

Hollenbeck's Cider Mill, 1265 State Route 392, Virgil  Website.

Run, don't walk! It's the last Forbidden Pie of the season at Hollenbeck's and the people have chosen. The Carmel Apple Pie with their signature crumble topping has be crowned champion and will be available through March 16. 

BLUEBERRY PIE

Anderson's Farm Market, 5887 NY-281, Homer; Website.

A simple Blueberry Pie from Anderson's Farm Market is the perfect dessert to share with company (or not). Not only can you satisfy your sweet tooth, but blueberries are one of the healthiest fruits on the market, so dig in. 

CHICKEN BACON RANCH PIZZA

Nicky C's, 12 N. West St., Homer; Website.

Pizza is everyone's favorite quick meal, but Nicky takes it to a the next level with their Chicken Bacon & Ranch pie. It's topped with grilled chicken, bacon, and a drizzle of ranch dressing. Enjoy it by the slice, or the pie - we don't judge.

Blueberry Pie
Blueberry Pie at Anderson's Market
20241111 chicken bacon ranch
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza at Nicky C's

SHEPARDS PIE

Hairy Tony's, 102 Main Street, Cortland; Website.

If you're the savory type, a Shepard's Pie at Hairy Tony's is acceptable on this day too. The traditional pub menu item is made with rich beef and vegetable stew cooked for hours with Guinness beer, crusted with cheddar mashed potatoes.

SPINACH PIE

Pita Gourmet, 41. Main Street, Cortland; Website.

This is a pie that would make Popeye proud.  Spinach, herbs, and lemon, all wrapped in a flaky pie crust will cure your hunger and leave you feeling strong! Try it dipped in tangy yogurt, for a bright pop of flavor.

PIE PARADISE

Reilly's Café, 8 E. Main Street, Marathon; Website

Reilly's Café is home to the pie cooler of your dreams. Stuffed full of meringues, fruit fill delicacies and pudding pies like grandma use to make, you're sure to find exactly the right slice to satisfy your sweet tooth.


Share your Cortland County adventures with us for a chance to be featured! Tag @experiencecortland607 and use hashtag #experiencecortland.

Categories: dining
Cortland County Travel Guide
Get Your Free
Travel Guide

Ready to discover the hidden gems and thrilling experiences Cortland County has to offer?

Join Our
Mailing List

Stay connected and uncover the local hotspots, unique experiences, and amazing outdoor adventures that make Cortland County unforgettable.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.