Pizzerias

Surround yourself with pizza, not negativity.

Pizzerias in Cortland County offer traditional NY style thin crust pizza or the thin crust that comes from a brick oven. You can try calzones, strombolis or order a whole sheet pizza.

BRIX Pubaria

Beer, brick-oven pizza, wings and more are served in a casual eatery with industrial-chic decor.

60 Main Street
Cortland, NY 13045

robby@brixpubaria.com

D.P. Dough Cortland

D.P. Dough delivers ooey, gooey, cheesy happiness on and around college campuses throughout the United States.

7 Tompkins Street
Cortland, NY 13045

East Side Bakery

Come share the sweet love of food at the East Side Bakery! Whether it's a simple half moon cookie or our awesome pizza, we love to feed you!

122 Elm Street
Cortland, NY 13045

christinearmstrong824@gmail.com

Little Italy Pizzeria

Locally owned and operated servicing the Cortland Area. Come sit in our dining room or get it delivered right to your dorm at SUNY Cortland campus!

125 South Main Street
Homer, NY 13077

Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria

Craving a taste of authentic New York pizza? Look no further than Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria!

1 Main Street
Marathon, NY

Nicky C's has the finest quality food made with the finest quality products. We are proud to reveal our fully renovated building with a few old favorites and a variety of new items to challenge your taste buds

12 N. West St.
Homer, NY

A Pizza & More

A Pizza & More is known for its authentic, thin crust NY style pizza, made exactly the way it was in the old neighborhood in NYC.

104 Main Street
Cortland, NY 13045

The Pizza Shop

Serving up delicious pizza slices in McGraw, the Pizza Shop offers stromboli, calzones, subs, chicken wings, and of course their specialty pizzas.

6 Main Street
McGraw, NY 13101

Pontillo's Pizzeria

Seventy years and counting, Pontillo’s Pizzeria has been a staple for Cortland. Sit down or take out, Pontillo’s offers traditional Italian-American style pizza.

124 Groton Avenue
Cortland, NY 13045

pizzacreator@yahoo.com

Pudgies Pizza & Subs

Since 1963 Pudiges Pizza & Subs has been known for its fluffy pizza dough and of course their sheet pizzas. Try one of their subs or their wings served three ways: char-grilled, boneless, or buffalo style.

75 North Main Street
Cortland, NY 13045

A Round Pizza

Locally owned and operated, A Round Pizza uses fresh ingredients in all their pizzas, wings, calzones, and salads. Free delivery in Cortland and Homer.

4943 Rt. 281
Cortland, NY 13045

Pizzerias

Enter Keywords

Surround yourself with pizza, not negativity.